The Klinghoffer Question

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
The Death of Klinghoffer

The Death of Klinghoffer

The most recent piece of bad news in the opera world is that the Metropolitan Opera has succumbed to pressure from several Jewish organizations and cancelled the international Live in HD telecast and radio broadcast of its new production of John Adams’s complex and controversial 1991 opera/oratorio The Death of Klinghoffer—which is about the Palestinian terrorist attack on the cruise ship Achille Lauro in 1985. And because Adams, librettist Alice Goodman, and stage director Peter Sellars had the chutzpah to dramatize the points of view of the terrorists as well as the victims, some people, including Leon Klinghoffer’s two daughters, felt the opera was anti-Semitic. (A satirical family scene just before the cruise was cut after the first American performances at the Brooklyn Academy of Music.) The Anti-Defamation League issued a statement that, although it didn’t find Klinghoffer itself anti-Semitic, “there is a concern the opera could be used in foreign countries to stir up anti-Israel sentiments or as a vehicle to promote anti-Semitism.”

The Met isn’t the first arts organization to cave in to pressure about Klinghoffer. After the 9/11 attack, the Boston Symphony Orchestra cancelled its scheduled performances of the choruses from Klinghoffer, in which both Jewish and Palestinian exiles voice their particular griefs and grievances (the best music in the opera and surely inspired by “Va pensiero,” Verdi’s great chorus of Jewish exiles in Nabucco), reminding us what some of us would prefer to forget, that we’re all human, even terrorists, and sometimes all too human. Are people afraid to face the fact that even the most monstrous human actions are still perpetrated by human beings, and that it’s one of the roles of a work of art to remind us that people are capable of terrible acts?

I still haven’t forgiven the BSO for canceling what might have been one of its most extraordinary concerts—a 1982 performance of Stravinsky’s Oedipus Rex, staged by Peter Sellars and narrated by Vanessa Redgrave—because some powerful donors objected to Redgrave’s pro-Palestinian politics. No one could accuse Oedipus Rex of being anti-Semitic. And as the composer points out in a New York Times article about the cancellation of the Klinghoffer telecast ( ), the director of the Anti-Defamation League has not seen the opera.

Some people question the Met’s original decision to telecast Klinghoffer, that it should have anticipated this backlash. Some have expressed worry for the owners of the many small theaters that screen the Met telecasts, who could become the indirect victims of demonstrators, incurring extra security and possible legal complications. And of course there’s worry about the Met itself and its precarious financial footing and strained relationship with labor unions. It doesn’t want to alienate its supporters.

Perhaps Gelb’s most important legacy is his commitment to important modern works. Klinghoffer is an ambitious, serious work, with some beautiful music, and, in my opinion, serious flaws. I was eager to see a new production without having to go to New York. Broadcasting and telecasting this work internationally offers a unique opportunity to open up a discussion about the nature of art and its relation to world events. Imagine doing that during the intermission instead of the usual interviews and behind the scenes chit-chat? Adams reports, in his Times interview, that Gelb told him that “unimaginable pressure” had been applied. Adams’s own seems the most telling: “The cancellation of the international telecast is a deeply regrettable decision and goes far beyond issues of ‘artistic freedom,’ and ends in promoting the same kind of intolerance that the opera’s detractors claim to be preventing.”

Lloyd Schwartz

About Lloyd Schwartz

Lloyd Schwartz, Senior Editor of Classical Music at New York Arts, is Frederick S. Troy Professor of English at the University of Massachusetts Boston and a regular commentator on music and the arts for NPR’s Fresh Air. For 35 years, he was Classical Music Editor of the Boston Phoenix. He is the author of three poetry collections and the editor of three volumes by and about poet Elizabeth Bishop, including the Library of America’s Elizabeth Bishop: Poems, Prose, and Letters. His poems, articles, and reviews have appeared in The New Yorker, The Atlantic, Vanity Fair, New Republic, Paris Review, Ploughshares, The Pushcart Prize, Best American Poetry, and, most recently, The Best of the Best American Poetry. He’s a three-time winner of the ASCAP-Deems Taylor Award for his writing about music, and the recipient of a grant from the Amphion Foundation for his writing on contemporary music. In 1994, he was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Criticism.

Dr. Schwartz’s writing also appears in our sister publication, The Berkshire Review for the Arts, especially in the summer, when he visits Tanglewood and other festivals in the Berkshires. Click here for a list of them.


  1. Jim Walsh

    According to the New York Times, the Opera Theater of St. Louis is to be congratulated and admired for its approach to this opera. Theirs was true to art and the truth that art seeks. John Adams and Peter Sellars are serious artists, not self-interested political hacks. In contrast to St. Louis, the Met, has shamefully cowered before a political operation run by Abraham Foxman in the service of the Likud Party in Israel. We expect this sort of thing in Putin’s Russia, but in New York? The saddest part of this whole episode is the betrayal of a certain aspect of Jewish tradition that has often supported and contributed to the protection of the oppressed through art and the performance of art. Self-satisfied strutters like Norman Podhoretz and Mr. Foxman are at the opposite end of that tradition. Perhaps some Fox-News-approved opera based on the spirit of John Wayne can be found as a substitute.

  2. The EditorThe Editor

    In this affair over John Adams’ opera, The Death of Klinghoffer, the participants have succeeded in making themselves look very bad indeed, above all Abe Foxman of the Jewish Anti-Defamation League and whatever kindred organizations which have not been specified in the reports—with Peter Gelb straggling obsequiously behind them. It is appalling that a special interest group can dictate what a major arts institution can present to the public, and that the chief officer of the institution should accept it so easily. Peter Gelb stated that the cancellation of the HD transmission was necessary to save the production itself at the Metropolitan Opera—which implies that the revered old house operates under the external control of groups like the ADL, which likes to consort with governments on a quasi-equal footing, but which exercises no legal power equivalent to that of a national government, certainly not that of the United States or Israel. We must ask whether the ADL’s censorship of the Metropolitan Opera’s work resembles more something like the Motion Picture Production Code or the repressive measures of a Fascist government, which represses art it considers politically unsuitable?

    Click here to read the rest of Michael Miller’s article.

Comments are closed.

A tip for our readers: How to get the most out of New York Arts and The Berkshire Review for the Arts.
What if I hate reading on computer screens, even tablets?
We get occasional inquiries from readers about whether we plan to launch a print edition of our arts journals. The answer is that we've given it some thought, and we're still thinking about it.
It is not only our older readers who object to reading them online. There are even some millennials who would rather read from paper. One of our readers got the simple idea of using the sites as sophisticated tables of contents. She prints out each article on three-hole paper and files them in a loose-leaf album. I've devoted a lot of time to finding the very best print and pdf facility there is. Just click on one of the icons at the top right of the article and print!
Click here to make your tax-deductible donation to The Arts Press, publisher of New York Arts and The Berkshire Review. Or click on the notice in the sidebar. The Arts Press is a sponsored project of Fractured Atlas, a non-profit arts service organization. Contributions for the charitable purposes of The Arts Press must be made payable to“Fractured Atlas” only and are tax-deductible to the extent permitted by law.